GlobusGate is California licensed contractor.
GlobusGate is California licensed contractor.

Vinyl vs. Aluminum Fencing: A Comprehensive Comparison

While wood has long been the traditional choice for fencing materials, modern alternatives like vinyl and aluminum fencing offer numerous benefits without the associated downsides. These modern options are easier to install and maintain and are often more affordable than wood. This makes them excellent choices for contemporary fencing projects. Let's explore the pros and cons of vinyl and aluminum fencing to help you decide which material is right for your needs, with insights from Globus Gates.

Ease of Installation

Wood fences demand significant effort to install, often involving complex steps and requiring regular maintenance such as cleaning, staining, or repainting. In contrast, vinyl and aluminum fences are easier to install and maintain. These modern alternatives typically require little to no upkeep and have lower upfront installation costs. 

Finding the Right Fit

Choosing the appropriate fencing material is crucial for the success of your project. The materials you select will impact the cost, appearance, longevity, and maintenance requirements of your fence. Two top contenders are vinyl and aluminum, and Globus Gates excels in both categories.

Material Composition

Vinyl, also known as PVC, is made from a polyvinyl chloride compound. Aluminum, on the other hand, is a metal. To determine which material suits your needs best, we’ll compare vinyl and aluminum fencing based on several critical factors.


If privacy is your primary concern, vinyl fencing is the best option. Vinyl fences can be constructed without any gaps between the slats, offering more privacy than aluminum fences, which typically have visible gaps. Vinyl fencing even surpasses many wood fences in terms of privacy because it allows for zero visibility through the slats.

However, if you prefer a more open feel and want to maintain a view of your surroundings, aluminum fencing is an excellent choice. While vinyl provides maximum privacy, aluminum allows for visibility and openness.

Strength and Durability

In terms of strength, aluminum fencing comes out on top. Aluminum is lightweight yet robust, capable of withstanding significant weight and impact. Although vinyl is also durable, lasting 20 to 30 years, it doesn’t match aluminum’s strength. For those seeking the strongest option available, ornamental steel fencing is another consideration.

Cost Comparison

The cost of vinyl versus aluminum fencing can vary depending on the specific product and style chosen. Sometimes, vinyl is less expensive, while other times, aluminum is more cost-effective. It’s essential to consider the lifetime costs of the fencing material. A product with a higher initial cost may offer better long-term value if it meets your needs and lasts longer without requiring replacement.


Both vinyl and aluminum fencing require minimal maintenance, making them equally appealing in this regard. Neither material needs repainting or restaining, and both are resistant to elements like bugs and mold, unlike wood. Whether you choose vinyl or aluminum, your fence will look great and function well for many years with little to no maintenance.

Aesthetic Appeal

The beauty of your fence depends on your personal preference. If you favor the classic look of wrought iron, aluminum fencing is an ideal choice. If you prefer the look of wood but want to avoid the associated maintenance, vinyl is a better option. Vinyl offers more flexibility in color and texture, often mimicking the appearance of wood more effectively.


Vinyl fencing outlasts wood fencing by a significant margin. Vinyl fences typically last about 20 to 30 years, while wood fences last around 10 to 15 years with proper maintenance. Vinyl fencing requires little to no maintenance, making it a more convenient and cost-effective choice in the long run.

Conclusion: Vinyl vs. Aluminum

Ultimately, there are no definitive rules about which fencing type is better. Both vinyl and aluminum are comparable in price, require minimal maintenance, and offer distinct styles. Your choice will largely depend on your aesthetic preference and functional needs.

If privacy is your priority, vinyl is the better option. If you want to maintain a view of your surroundings, aluminum is ideal. For those looking to mimic wood without the upkeep, vinyl is preferable. For a classic, elegant look, aluminum is the way to go.

Professional Installation

Regardless of your choice, whether vinyl or aluminum, Globus Gates is here to help you select and install the perfect fencing solution. Our offerings include industry-leading Vinyl Fencing and Elite Aluminum Fencing. Visit our showroom to see the materials up close and make an informed decision.

Globus Gates is dedicated to providing enhanced security, privacy, and an improved image for your home with high-quality fencing solutions. Contact us today to find the ideal fence for your needs.

Order a consultation

Just leave a request and we will provide you with professional advice.

Request a call

Just leave a request and we will provide you with professional advice.